Which one is best for for having different response base on user role :using 1 resource or multiple resources?

I want to send different response base on user role in my controller, in 2 project I come with a way to approach this.
1- my first approach is having a resource for each response.
my controller is like this :

$user = $request->user;
$role = $user->role;
$firstPost = Post::where('user_id',$user->getKey())->first();
$postResourceBuilder = new PostResourceBuilder($firstPost,$role); 
return $postResourceBuilder->getResource();

then in my PostResourceBuilder:

class PostResourceBuilder {
  private $post;
  private $role;
  public function __construct($post,$role){
    $this->post = $post;
    $this->role = $role;
  }
  public function getResource(){
    switch($this->role){
      case 'Client':
       return new ClientPostResource($this->post);
      default :
       return new DefaultPostResource($this->post);
    }
  }
}

but in another project I came with another approach:
2- I make a new Resource class and all my Resources extends it:

class BaseResource extends JsonResource
{
    protected $mode = 'Default';

    public function setMode($mode)
    {
        $this->mode = $mode;
    }
    public function toArray($request)
    {
        return call_user_func([$this,$this->getMethodName()],$request);
    }

    public function getDefaultResource($request)
   {
        return parent::toArray($request);
    }
   protected function getMethodName(){

      $methodName = 'get'.$this->mode.'Resource';
      return  method_exists($this,$methodName) ? $methodName : 'getDefaultResource';

   }

}

then in my PostResource :

class PostResource extends BaseResource
{
  public function getClientResource($request)
  {
   //...
  }

}

and in my controller :

$user = $request->user;
$role = $user->role;
$firstPost = Post::where('user_id',$user->getKey())->first();
$postResource = new PostResource($firstPost,$role);
$postResource->setMode($role);
// if it's collection
// $postResource->collection->each->setMode($role)
return $postResource;

after I doing these I wonder which one is better

from Newest questions tagged laravel-5 - Stack Overflow https://ift.tt/2ruMHfn
via IFTTT